DCSD 2025 AP Matrix

AID 1754330 · View on Simbli

Agenda Item

e. ERATE Category 2 (Not to exceed $2,984,452.83) ~ Updated 3.7.2025

Summary: Presented by: Dr. Kermit Belcher, Chief Information Officer, Division of Information, and Instructional Technology
Request: It is requested the Board of Education approve the ERATE Category 2 awards for the following eligible purchases for services from the following vendors in the amounts listed below, as the lowest responsible, responsive bids, in an amount not to exceed $2,984,452.83. The district cost should not exceed $447,667.93 after the 90% Erate discount.


$554,680.23 CDWG Access Level Switches and associated components for new school locations (New Cross Keys, New Dresden and New Sequoyah)
$2,429,772.60 MGT Wireless Access Points and Licenses
Why: This recommendation provides the DeKalb County School District with Category 2 Erate for all eligible services that are classified as internal connections within a school building that support the attachment of student devices to the “Top of Rack” Category 1 Switch. DCSD shall receive a 85% reimbursement or discount based on free and reduced data. ERATE is administered by the “Universal Service Administrative Company” (USAC).
Details: DCSD utilizes ERATE to leverage the purchasing dollars of the “Universal Service Administrative Company” (USAC). ERATE allows DCSD to extend purchasing power for approved eligible services and seek reimbursement.

This year DCSD applied for the following reimbursement for services.


Access Level Switches and associated components for the new (Cross Keys HS, Sequoyah MS/HS Complex and Dresden ES)
Wireless Access Points and Licenses for providing wireless access for students at (Cross Keys HS, Sequoyah MS/HS Complex and Dresden ES and existing locations). After reviewing all criteria and costs, the bid is awarded to MGT.
Financial impact: If ERATE is awarded, these numbers are before 85% reimbursement. The pre-discounted amount shall not exceed $2,984,452.83. The district cost should not exceed $447,667.93 after the 85% Erate discount.


$554,680.23 CDWG Access Level Switches and associated components for new school locations (New Cross Keys, New Dresden and New Sequoyah)
$2,429,772.60 MGT Wireless Access Points and Licenses


General Funds
306.2210.573400.80336.7600.9990.8010.070.0000
Contact: Dr. Kermit Belcher, Chief Information Officer, Division of Information and Instructional Technology, 678.676.1274
Effective: March 2025
Status: Approved by Office of Legal Affairs
                                                                   VENDOR DECISION/EVALUATION MATRIX
SCHOOL OR LIBRARY NAME: DeKalb Co. SD                                                                                         Date: 12/16/2025   E-rate: 2025-26

                                                             Choose and           Int. Connections or
                                                             Indicate the service MIBS or     Basic
                                      CATEGORY 2:            (1 per Matrix):      Maint.:
Eligible Service:                                            →'→'→'→'→'→          Internal Connections (APs)
                                                                                  SERVICE PROVIDERS
                         Total
                         Points
Factors                  Available       VENDOR 1                  VENDOR 2              VENDOR 3            VENDOR 4
                                            AiOS                     MGT              CDW Juniper 34      CDW Juniper 24
                                         Install Only                                   No Licenses         No Licenses
Cost of K                               $215,000.00            $2,429,772.60           $1,937,951.67       $1,611,402.23
Price                            25                     15                     20                    22                  23
Past Experience /
Relationship with
Respondent                       20                     10                     15                    15                 15
Technical Capability,
Quality of Work,
Ability to Provide
Services Purchased /
Turnkey Solution,
Qualified Personnel              20                     10                     18                    18                 18
Responsiveness to
Form 470                         20                      4                     20                    13                 13
Changeover Costs                 10                      5                      5                     5                  5
Willingness to invoice
via SPI                          5                       3                      3                     5                  5
TOTAL POINTS:                  100                      47                     81                    78                 79

Winning bidder based on most points was:                     MGT                    Selection team member initials:           JS
Nonresponsive bidders, if any:                               N/A
NOTES:
Of the bids received, only one was complete (from MGT). AiOS only quoted installation and project management - no equipment or licenses. CDW-G did not
quote separate licenses for the 6400 existing APs, nor did they quote the correct number of gateways, which made it difficult to assess their bid. Due to these
issues of bid responsiveness, both AiOS and CDW-G lost points on the matrix. MGT's bid is complete and is the most compatible with the District's current
wireless equipment. Due to these factors, along with the District's prior good experience with MGT, the bid is awarded to MGT. Please note that 5-year licenses
were used for evaluation purposes, where applicable.
**** NOTE: POINT VALUES AND FACTORS MAY BE CHANGED PER YOUR OWN CRITERIA, BUT PRICE MUST
REMAIN THE MOST HEAVILY WEIGHTED FACTOR AND THE "TOTAL POINTS" OF ALL FACTORS MUST ADD TO 100%****