13. Texas Efficacy Research

AID 1833284 · View on Simbli

Agenda Item

g. Purchase of Amira Tutor, Supplemental High-Dosage Tutoring (Not to exceed $600,000)

Summary: Presented by: Ms. Stacy E. Stepney, Chief Academic Officer, Division of Curriculum and Instruction
Request: It is requested that the Board of Education approve the purchase of Amira Tutor, a high-dosage, research-based tutoring program to support foundational reading skills, fluency, and reading comprehension development in kindergarten through third grade, in an amount not to exceed $600,000.
Why: The DeKalb County School District (DCSD) administers the Northwest Evaluation Association Measure of Academic Progress (MAP) three times per year. The 2025 spring MAP Fluency data results in the areas of phonics and word recognition are as follows:




Phonics and Word Recognition


Grade
Below Expectation
Approaching Expectation
Meets Expectation
Exceeds Expectation


Kindergarten
27%
16%
25%
32%


First
52%
46%
2%
0%


Second
96%
0%
4%
0%


Third
95%
0%
5%
0%




Amira ISIP is the Georgia Department of Education’s approved reading and dyslexia screener provided to local school districts at no cost. The District is seeking to adopt and purchase Amira Tutor, a supplemental tutoring program that algins directly to the Amira Assess. Amira Tutor will provide high-dosage, evidence-based, AI-guided, 1:1 tutoring to support teaching and learning. Real-time micro interventions are individualized and use research-based techniques and explicit decoding strategies to enhance foundational reading skills.

Pursuant to Board Policy DJE (III.D.3.g.2), the purchase of Amira Tutor does not require a competitive bid because it meets the policy definition of supplemental resources needed for instruction. In addition, Amira Tutor was evaluated and selected by qualified professional personnel based on sound pedagogical judgment and in the school district’s best interest.
Details: Amira ISIP provides a comprehensive and culturally responsive assessment system that evaluates key early literacy components such as phonological awareness, decoding, fluency, and comprehension-many of which can be completed in 15-20 minutes. The voice-enabled technology listens as students read aloud, detects errors with high reliability and validity, and generates actionable data reports that support differentiated instruction and early identification of reading difficulties, including dyslexia risk.

Amira acts in three essential roles: a dyslexia screener and diagnostic tool, a skilled instructional assistant, and a personalized reading coach. These roles are particularly valuable for early learners who benefit from responsive, individualized practice grounded in the science of reading.

For educators, Amira Tutor enhances classroom efficiency by allowing small group, whole group, or individual support by delivering immediate feedback through an AI-powered 1:1 tutor. For students, Amira Tutor fosters independence and engagement through interactive read-aloud experiences and real-time positive reinforcement. This tool is especially effective for supporting diverse learners thanks to its universal design features and multilingual sensitivity.

Overall, Amira Tutor empowers K-3 teachers with the data and tools needed to deliver responsive instruction, monitor progress, and close early literacy gaps, making it an asset in building foundational reading proficiency across all student groups. The selection of the Amira Tutor followed a two-round review process:


Round 1 (March 17, 2025): The five GADOE approved vendors presented their universal reading and dyslexia screener in person. A total of 15 participants attended, including central office coordinators, directors, assistant superintendents, and chiefs. Participants provided structured feedback and posed questions regarding instructional design, alignment with science of reading, and support for differentiated instruction of each resource.



Round 2 (April 3, 2025): Vendors addressed specific questions that arose in Round 1.
Financial impact: The total contract amount will not exceed $600,000.




120.2100.553200.26021.7210.1613.8010.035.2025
GEER II Dyslexia
Communication-Web Subscription


100-1000-553200-00011-7580-9990-8010-035-000
Communication-Web Subscription


100-2220-530000-00011-7580-9990-8010-035-0000
Purchased Professional/Technical Services
Contact: Ms. Stacy E. Stepney, Chief Academic Officer, Division of Curriculum & Instruction, 678-676-0731
Dr. Sean R. Tartt, Deputy Chief Academic Officer, Division of Curriculum & Instruction, 678-676-0731
Dr. Penny Mosley, Assistant Superintendent K-5 Curriculum & Instruction, Division of Curriculum & Instruction, 678-676-0137
Dr. Lynn Angus Ramos, Director, Literacy, Division of Curriculum & Instruction, 678-676-0136
Mrs. Lummie Baker, Director, Educational Media and Instructional Materials, Division of Curriculum & Instruction, 678-676-2421
Effective: July 15, 2025- June 30, 2026
Status: Approved by Office of Legal Affairs
     2024


         Texas
         Efficacy
         Research


The Science of Reading + AI = Growth
Efficacy Research

Evidence from Texas
                      Abstract
                      To support the Texas Education Association’s (TEA’s) review of
                      efficacy, Amira worked with Amira-using districts in Texas to
                      create a sample of using and non-using students. YoY growth in
                      STAAR score performance was then used to isolate Amira’s
                      impact.

                      Amira generated gains that averaged 36 STAAR points per
                      student. @Dosage students gained roughly 9 Percentile Ranks
                      compared to non-using peers.

                      After reviewing the test data, the TEA validated Amira’s impact
                      by granting one of the few 1416 waivers awarded. Amira’s
                      accelration takes hold when students work about 15 to 20
                      minutes a week. Peak effect is achieved via 2-4 short sessions
                      weekly, consisting of ~30 minutes of Amira-scaffolded practice.


                                                                                        1
What Does This Research Prove About Amira’s Efficacy?
When controlling for the initial ability cohort as measured by students’ quartiles at their
2nd grade EOY benchmark assessment, Texas students who used Amira Tutor at the
recommended dosage in 3rd grade significantly outperformed students who did not.




                                                                                    Who Conducted and
                                                                                    Published the Research?

                                                                               This research was conducted with X Texas
                                                                               Independent School Districts
                                                                               by the Amira Research team.

                                                                               Results were submitted to and reviewed
                                                                               by the Texas Education Agency as part of
                                                                               the 1416 Waiver approval.




                                                                                                                          2
              Why is this research consistent with the
                        Science of Reading?

  Decades of research has shown that the most effective instructional method is 1:1
tutoring. The economics of human capital have created the so-called 2 sigma problem.



                                                      Students need 1:1 assistance and educators
                                                      have had no way to afford providing a personal
                                                      tutor.

                                                      Working 1:1 with students, Amira brings the
                                                      power of individual tutoring to every single
                                                      child.

                                                      In research conducted by Utah, North Dakota,
                                                      Louisiana and in this study for the Texas
                                                      Education Agency, Amira has shown the ability
                                                      to power accelerated growth rates superior to
                                                      human high dossage tutoring programs.




                                                                                                       3
What did this study show?
Amira's Reading Suite consisting of Assess, Instruct, and Tutor, has had significant impact on student growth inTexas, as measured by STAAR
scores.
   Amira Assess accurately predicts STAAR scores, with a correlation of 0.8 between ISIP 2nd grade EOY scores and 3rd grade EOY STAAR scores.
   Amira Instruct improves STAAR scores, with an average gain of 16 points for students using the app at the recommended dosage.
   Amira Tutor substantially enhances STAAR performance, with students working more than 30 minutes a week growing with an effect size of .45.
The research conclusively demonstrates that Amira’s Reading Suite predicts STAAR’s results and drives STAAR outcomes. Districts using Assess
will have better information for shaping instruction. Districts using Instruct & Tutor will see better results.




                                                                                                           Grade Level Coverage
                                                              Subject      Product Name       Overview      (HB 1416 Applicable        Usage
                                                                                                                  Grades)
                                                                           Amira Learning
                                                                                                                                      15 min
                                                                RLA        Distributed by       video             K-6 (4-6)
                                                                                                                                    4x per week
                                                                           Amira or HMH

                                                                           HMH Read                                                   20 min
                                                                RLA        180 Flex             video            3-12 (4-11)
                                                                                                                                    4x per week


                                                                           IXL Language                                               30 min
                                                                RLA        Arts                 video            PK-12 (4-11)
                                                                                                                                    2x per week


                                                                                                                                                  4
                                         Where Can One Access the Full Study?
 The TEA’s review and approval for the HB 1416 waiver is here.

 Background is available on the Amira Learning website. You can also reach
 out to info@amiralearning.com.


Related Studies
Several other studies support Amira’s impact on literacy growth:        Summary & Conclusion
           Evaluation and Training Institute (2023): Found Amira        The research confirms that Amira generates
           significantly outperformed a control group in Utah’s Early   growth equivalent to good, human-delivered
           Intervention Reading Software Program (Read Report).         High Dosage Tutoring.


           Mostow et al. (Carnegie Mellon): Demonstrated                The 1416 waiver is keyed to the legislative
           that AI-powered reading tutors can be as effective           requirement to demonstrate HDT-level impact.
           as human tutors (Read Study).                                Amira is now in use at more than 70 Texas
                                                                        Districts producing gains that meet or exceed
                                                                        this threshold.
           Poulsen et al. (DePaul): Showed Amira’s effectiveness
           for bilingual students (Read Study)



                                                                                                                        5