3. DCSD K-5 Phonics Vendor Selection Tool (1)

AID 1831397 · View on Simbli

Agenda Item

a. Adoption and Purchase of 95 Phonics Core Program from 95 Percent Group LLC (Not to exceed $3,000,000)

Summary: Presented by: Ms. Stacy E. Stepney, Chief Academic Officer, Division of Curriculum & Instruction
Request: It is requested that the Board of Education approve the purchase of the 95 Phonics Core Program from 95 Percent Group to supplement existing English language arts instruction in an amount not to exceed $3,000,000. This standalone phonics program will support foundational reading skills development in kindergarten through fifth grade by strengthening direct instruction and practice of foundational skills aligned to structured literacy.
Why: The DeKalb County School District (DCSD) administers the Northwest Evaluation Association Measure of Academic Progress (MAP) three times per year. The 2025 spring MAP Fluency data results in the areas of phonics and word recognition are as follows:




Phonics and Word Recognition


Grade
Below Expectation
Approaching Expectation
Meets Expectation
Exceeds Expectation


Kindergarten
27%
16%
25%
32%


First
52%
46%
2%
0%


Second
96%
0%
4%
0%


Third
95%
0%
5%
0%




The District is seeking to adopt and purchase a phonics supplemental resource to support teaching and learning. The phonics supplemental resource will provide access to evidence-based resources, increase support of sound instructional practices, and engage students in explicit, systematic, cumulative, and diagnostic phonics instruction.

According to Board Policy IFA-Instructional Materials and Content, the District must provide access to instructional resources including, but not limited to, textbooks and supplemental materials. Board Policy IFA requires the presentation of recommendations for adoption to the Board of Education.
Details: Per the Georgia Early Literacy Act (House Bill 538), local school districts may purchase supplemental resources using the High-Quality Instructional Materials (HQIM) Rubric. The HQIM Rubric includes the following components that must be considered when selecting supplemental materials to ensure alignment to foundational reading skills and science of reading:

Research Alignment



Explicit, Systematic, Cumulative, and Diagnostic Instruction



Related Elements (alignment to Georgia’s ELA standards and assessments)



Phonological and Phonemic Awareness



Phonics and Word Study



Text Reading and Fluency



Vocabulary



Listening comprehension and Reading Comprehension

The selection of the 95 Phonics Core Program followed a rigorous two-round review process: 


Round 1 (March 24, 2025): Four vendors presented their phonics programs in person. A total of 27 participants attended, including classroom teachers, academic coaches, and central office coordinators, directors, assistant superintendents, and chiefs. Participants provided structured feedback and posed questions regarding instructional design, alignment with curriculum, and support for differentiated instruction of each resource. 



Round 2 (May 1, 2025): Vendors addressed specific questions that arose in Round 1.



In accordance with Board Policy DJE (III.D.3.g.1-2), qualified personnel evaluated the four vendors using the components of the HQIM Rubric and selected 95 Phonics Core Program based on sound pedagogical judgment and in the best interest of the school district.
Financial impact: The total contract amount will not exceed $3,000,000.




100-1000-553200-00011-7580-9990-8010-035-0000
Communication-Web Subscription


100-2210-561000-00011-7580-9990-8010-035-0000
Supplies


100-1000-564000-00011-7580-9990-8010-035-0000
Digital/Electronic Textbooks


100-1000-564100-00011-7580-9990-8010-035-0000
Textbooks - Printed


100-1000-564200-00011-7580-9990-8010-035-0000
Books (Other)


100-2220-530000-00011-7580-9990-8010-035-0000
Purchased Professional/Technical Services
Contact: Ms. Stacy E. Stepney, Chief Academic Officer, Division of Curriculum & Instruction, 678-676-0731
Dr. Sean R. Tartt, Deputy Chief Academic Officer, Division of Curriculum & Instruction, 678-676-0731
Dr. Penny Mosley, Assistant Superintendent K-5 Curriculum & Instruction, Division of Curriculum & Instruction, 678-676-0137
Dr. Lynn Angus Ramos, Director, Literacy, Division of Curriculum & Instruction, 678-676-0136
Mrs. Lummie Baker, Director, Educational Media and Instructional Materials, Division of Curriculum & Instruction, 678-676-2421
Effective: July 15, 2025- June 30, 2026
Status: Approved by Office of Legal Affairs
   DCSD K-5 Phonics Vendor Selection Tool

* This form will record your name, please fill your name.




  1. Vendor:

           95 Core Phonics Program


           U-FLI (University of Florida Literacy Institute)


           Fundations


           Heggerty




  2. Science of Reading Base: Incorporates evidence-based reading
     practices and cognitive science research.

           Exceeds


           Proficient


           Developing


           Does Not Meet




  3. Standards Aligned: Aligns to the Foundations Domain of GaDOE's new
     ELA standards.

           Exceeds


           Proficient


           Developing


           Does Not Meet
4. Learning Progression: Skills are introduced in a logical and research-
   based progression.

       Exceeds


       Proficient


       Developing


       Does Not Meet




5. DCSD Literacy Framework: Instruction can be implemented within 30
   minutes per day.

       Exceeds


       Proficient


       Developing


       Does Not Meet




6. Multisensory Instruction: Includes visual, auditory, kinesthetic, and
   tactile learning elements (e.g. tapping, Elkonin boxes, auditory
   discrimination exercises).

       Exceeds


       Proficient


       Developing


       Does Not Meet
 7. Targeted Support: Offers support for Tier 1, Tier 2 and Tier 3 struggling
    readers.

        Exceeds


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet




 8. Clear Instructional Routines: Concepts are clearly explained with
    modeling and guided practice.

        Exceeds


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet




 9. Explicit & Systematic Phonics: Clear and sequential teaching of sound-
    symbol relationships activities.

        Exceeds


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet




10. Phonological/Phonemic Instruction: Includes structured oral language
    activities.

        Exceeds


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet
11. Word Study: Offers sorting, word building, word mapping to reinforce
    skills activities.

        Exceeds


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet




12. Decodable Texts: Reinforces phonics patterns and high-frequency
    words.

        Exceed


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet




13. Diagnostic: Embedded assessments and feedback loops are available to
    guide instruction.

        Exceeds


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet




14. Morphology: Teaches prefixes, suffixes, and root words for vocabulary
    growth.

        Exceeds


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet
15. Differentiation: Offers support for diverse learners, including English
    Language Learners (ELLs) and students with disabilities.

        Exceeds


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet




16. Structure: The program supports whole-group, small-group, and/or
    independent learning.

        Exceeds


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet




17. Professional Learning: PD supports effective use of the tool (in-person,
    virtual, and/or on-demand, webinars).

        Exceeds


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet




18. Professional Learning: Offers ongoing PD and technical support
    (coaching, website with FAQ, live online support).

        Exceeds


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet
19. Print: Materials are included (e.g. teacher manuals, student workbooks,
    decodable texts, online resources).

        Exceeds


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet




20. Digital: Includes digital component or online platform for students and
    teachers.

        Exceeds


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet




21. Scripted lessons: Materials support teachers who may be unfamiliar with
    explicit phonics instruction.

        Exceeds


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet




22. Supplemental materials: Materials for home use to engage parents and
    caregivers.

        Exceeds


        Proficient


        Developing


        Does Not Meet
    23. Culturally responsive & engaging: Materials address home language,
        dialect, and various cultures and backgrounds.

               Exceeds


               Proficient


               Developing


               Does Not Meet




    24. Total Product Score:




    25. Summary of Strengths:




    26. Summary of Weaknesses:




    27. Additional Comments:




This content is neither created nor endorsed by Microsoft. The data you submit will be sent to the form owner.

                                                 Microsoft Forms