Final Evaluation for RFP 24-589 English Learners Program Evaluation and Master Planning

AID 1679805 · View on Simbli

Agenda Item

a. English Learners Program Evaluation and Master Planning (Not to exceed $183,136.97)

Summary: Presented by: Dr. Norman C. Sauce III, Chief of Student Services, Division of Student Services
Request: It is requested that the Board of Education approve the award for RFP 24-589 for the English Learners Program Evaluation and Master Planning to RMC Research Corporation as the most responsive and responsible bidder to perform a comprehensive program evaluation, and master development of the DCSD English Learners Department for an amount not to exceed $183,136.97.
Why: The desired outcome for this program evaluation and master planning is to provide the school district with an evaluation of and recommendations for improving the academic and developmental outcomes and experiences for our English learners, and in how we partner with their families. The recommendations and master planning are expected to address any aspects of academic programming and operations of the school district that enhance and/or hinders their implementation.

It is the expectation of the program evaluation and master-planning process to gather information about our English Learner Department and ESOL services, systems of support for English learners and families, for ensuring their equitable access to high quality instruction at all schools, and timely and effective communication. The evaluation should include analysis of, including but not limited to: tier one curriculum and instructional practices, service models, assessment practices, reclassification practices, interpretation and translation access and efficacy, school-to-home communication practices, professional development needs, resource allocation relative to state and national standards to serve the learning and language development needs of our English learners receiving ESOL services. Additionally, we are seeking to evaluate the vertical and horizontal articulation of language development instructional practices in grades K-12 for our English learners receiving ESOL services.

Components of the English Learners Department evaluation and master planning must include, but are not limited to:


Evidence of alignment to state and national (WIDA) English Language Development standards.
Evidence of language development that impacts the teaching and learning of content standards across the curriculum and assessments.
A review of the district organization chart and job descriptions to maximize direction and support for impacting change to deliver better instruction for English learners.
Evidence of consistency and fidelity in the implementation of ESOL service models district wide.
Evidence of technology integration across K-12 ESOL services.
Evidence of curriculum and assessment materials that reflect the diverse language development needs of our student population.
A review of the policies and controls that govern the multi-level English Learners department and ESOL services.
A review of the DCSD budgets to support the review, revision, and implementation of ESOL Curriculum, and ESOL services including identification, screening, assessment, reclassification and exit processes.
Details: In accordance with the formal procurement procedures published by the Georgia Department of Education, the Request for Proposal (RFP) was issued May 23, 2024. Electronic notification was sent to 195 vendors from the DCSD vendor list, 2,638 vendors through the State of Georgia Procurement Registry (GPR), and 687 vendors through IonWave, the DeKalb County School District’s solicitation portal. The solicitation was advertised in the Champion Newspaper for two (2) consecutive weeks beginning May 23, 2024. Four (4) proposals were received on June 25, 2024, for the English Learners Program Evaluation and Master's Planning. Three (3) proposals were deemed responsive and evaluated on the following criteria: Firm’s Overview, Scope of Services, Firm’s Relevant Experience and Expertise, Professional References, and Cost of Services. The firm’s profile including ownership structure, history, and organization chart; scope of services including methodology and strategies; relevant experiences in comparable K-12 school districts; and three written references.
Financial impact: The financial impact to the general funds for school year 2024-2025 will not exceed the amount $183,136.97.

Division of Student Services Charge Code:
100.2300.530000.00011.8740.9990.8010.094.0000
Contact: Dr. Norman C. Sauce III, Chief of Student Services,, Division of Student Services, 678-676-1079

Dr. Evelyn Hall, Executive Director, English Learners Program/Title III and DeKalb International Screening Center, Division of Student Services, 678-676-6602
Effective: August 19, 2024 - August 18, 2025
Status: Solicitation Reviewed and Approved by General Counsel
                         English Language Learners Program Evaluation and Master Planning
                                       Final Evaluation Form - RFP No. 24-589

                                                                                           EVALUATION




                                                                                                               FIRM'S RELEVANT EXPERIENCE AND EXPERTISE
                                                         FIRM'S OVERVIEW/COMPANY PROFILE




                                                                                                                                                                                                       TOTAL EVALUATION SCORE
                                                                                                                                                          PROFESSIONAL REFERENCES




                                                                                                                                                                                                                                EVALUATION RANKING
                                                                                           SCOPE OF SERVICES




                                                                                                                                                                                    COST OF SERVICES
English Language Learners Program Evaluation and
Master Planning
RFP 24-589


           APPLICANTS              POINTS AVAILABLE     100 150 125 75                                                                                                              50                 500

     RMC Research Corporation                      Score 100 150 120                                                                                             33                      50                 453 1st
     Together Striving for Hope                    Score 28 45 35                                                                                                15                      38                 161 3rd
           Zia Learning Inc.                       Score 92 144 85                                                                                               27                      37                 385 2nd
     Public Consulting Group LLC                   Score